A foot of fresh snow on the roof looks pretty. Three days later it's settled, it rained on top of it, and icicles are forming along the gutters. Now you're wondering if you should be up there with a shovel.
Short answer: please don't get on the roof. And most of the time, you don't need to touch the snow at all. But there are a few situations where pulling some of it down from the ground is smart, and a few where you should call someone right away.
Most Roofs Can Handle Normal Snow
Houses in Northeast Ohio are built for winter. A typical pitched roof in good shape can carry the snow we usually get, and a lot of it slides or melts off on its own.
The problem is that not all snow weighs the same. The University of Minnesota Extension says snow can range from about 3 pounds per cubic foot when it's light and fluffy to about 21 pounds per cubic foot when it's wet and heavy. Ice is around 57 pounds per cubic foot.
So a foot of fluffy powder and a foot of wet, packed snow with a layer of ice underneath are completely different loads. That's why the storm that worries us isn't always the biggest one. It's the heavy, wet one, or the one that gets rained on, or snow that keeps piling up for weeks without a thaw. Folks in the snowbelt east of Cleveland, in Lake and Geauga counties, see that more than most.
When Roof Snow Is Actually a Problem
Think about raking some snow off if you see any of these:
- Ice dams and big icicles at the eaves. Snow melts higher up, refreezes at the cold edge, and backs water up under the shingles. Removing a few feet of snow along the edge gives meltwater less to feed on. Our ice dam prevention guide covers the root causes.
- Deep drifts. Wind piles snow on the low side of a roofline, behind a chimney, or where an addition meets the main house. Drifts can be much heavier than the rest of the roof.
- Heavy, wet snow or rain on snow that has been sitting for a while.
- Low-slope sections, like a porch roof, garage, or a flat addition, where snow doesn't slide off.
- An older roof or one that's already sagging, leaking, or has known damage.
FEMA's Warning Signs of an Overloaded Roof
FEMA's Snow Load Safety Guide lists signs that a roof is under too much stress. The big ones for homeowners:
- Sagging ceilings or a roofline that dips
- Popping, cracking, or creaking noises
- Doors or windows that suddenly won't open or close
- New cracks in walls, ceilings, or masonry
- Cracked or split wood framing in the attic
- Severe leaks
FEMA's advice if you see these: get everyone out of the house and call your local building department or a structural engineer for an inspection. This is not the time to start raking. Pulling snow off a roof that's already struggling can make things worse, and you don't want to be standing under it.
How to Rake Snow Safely (From the Ground)
If your roof is fine but you want to take the load or ice dam risk down, a roof rake is the right tool. Here's how to do it without hurting yourself or your shingles:
- Stay on the ground. OSHA says snow should be removed from the ground with roof rakes or drag lines whenever possible. Working on a snowy roof is a fall risk, and so is a ladder on ice.
- Use a rake with wheels or rollers. IBHS (the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety) recommends one because the wheels keep the blade above the shingles and cut down on scraping.
- Leave a couple inches. You're not trying to get the roof clean. Scraping down to the shingles knocks off granules and can tear tabs, especially when they're cold and brittle.
- Pull straight down the slope, not sideways, so you don't catch shingle edges.
- Work the first few feet above the gutters, which is where ice dams start. You don't need to reach the ridge.
- Watch for power lines. IBHS warns to stay clear of where power lines enter your home, and OSHA says to keep tools at least 10 feet from overhead lines and treat every line as live. Metal poles conduct electricity.
- Stand clear of the slide. Snow comes down fast and heavy. Keep kids, pets, and yourself out of the drop zone, and wear a hat and eye protection.
- Don't chip at ice with a hammer, shovel, or ice pick. You'll do more damage to the roof than the ice will.
When to Call a Pro Instead
Call for help if:
- You'd have to climb a ladder or get on the roof to reach the snow
- The roof is two stories or steep
- Power lines run near the area you need to clear
- You're seeing FEMA's warning signs above
- Water is already coming inside
If water is getting in, our post on what to do about a roof leak in winter walks through the short-term steps. If you own a commercial building with a flat roof, read our flat roof snow load guide, since the rules are different there.
The Real Fix Happens Before the Snow
If you have to rake your roof every winter to keep ice dams away, that's a sign something else is going on. Most of the time it's heat getting into the attic from poor insulation, air leaks, or weak ventilation. That warm attic melts the snow from underneath, and the water refreezes at the edge.
We can check your ventilation, insulation clues, flashing, and ice and water barrier at the eaves, then tell you what would actually stop the problem. Our attic frost and condensation post explains more of what we look for.
Get a Free Winter Roof Inspection
Worried about the snow on your roof, ice dams at the gutters, or a leak that only shows up in winter? We'll take a look, show you photos, and give you a straight answer and a clear, itemized estimate if anything needs work. No pressure.
We inspect and repair roofs across Northeast Ohio, including Cleveland, Lakewood, Parma, Westlake, Elyria, Medina, Mentor, and Painesville. Learn more about our roof repair and roof inspection services. Inspections and quotes are always free.
Pring Roofing has served Northeast Ohio since 1936. We're fully insured, hold a BBB A+ rating, and are an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, an Elevate (formerly Firestone) Licensed Applicator, and a Carlisle authorized applicator.
Call (216) 941-6298 or email contact@pringroofing.com, or request a free quote online. We answer 7 days a week, 7am to 10pm.
Sources: FEMA P-957, Snow Load Safety Guide; University of Minnesota Extension, "Snow Loads on Buildings"; Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS), "Ice Dams: Prevent Them and Your Roof Will Thank You"; OSHA, "Falls and Other Hazards to Workers Removing Snow from Rooftops and Other Elevated Surfaces" (OSHA 3513). This post is general information. Every roof is different, so if you're unsure, have yours looked at before you start pulling snow down.
