You notice a brown ring on the ceiling, or a damp spot on the wall right next to the fireplace. Or maybe you hear dripping inside the chimney after a storm. If you live in an older Cleveland-area home with a brick chimney, you are far from alone.
Chimneys are one of the most leak-prone spots on any roof. The Masonry Advisory Council puts it simply: a chimney is "one of the most vulnerable parts of a structure because it is exposed to weathering on all sides." And here in Northeast Ohio, winter makes every small gap worse.
Here's how to figure out where the water is coming from, and what actually fixes it.
Why Chimney Leaks Get Worse in a Cleveland Winter
The Chimney Safety Institute of America (CSIA) says water causes more damage to masonry chimneys than fire does. Brick acts like a sponge. It soaks up water and wicks it inward.
Add our freeze-thaw cycles and you get a problem that grows on its own. Water seeps into a small crack, freezes, expands, and widens the crack. Then it thaws, more water gets in, and the cycle repeats. A hairline crack in October can be a real leak by February.
That's why fall and early winter are the best time to catch chimney problems, before a season of snow and ice goes to work on them.
The 4 Most Common Sources of a Chimney Leak
1. Failed or Poorly Installed Flashing
Flashing is the metal that seals the gap where your roof meets the chimney. CSIA describes it as the seal that keeps rainwater from running down the chimney into your living space, where it can damage ceilings and walls and rot rafters and joists.
A proper chimney flashing job has two layers:
- Step flashing woven in with the shingles along the sides of the chimney.
- Counterflashing set into the mortar joints of the brick and lapped down over the step flashing.
What we find on a lot of leaking chimneys around here: flashing that's just smeared with roofing cement or caulk, old flashing that's pulled away from the brick, or counterflashing that was never cut into the mortar at all. Tar and caulk can buy you a season. They are not a fix.
Clue it's the flashing: the stain shows up on the ceiling or wall right next to the chimney, and it gets worse during wind-driven rain or when snow melts on the roof.
2. A Cracked Chimney Crown
The crown is the concrete or mortar "roof" on top of the chimney. Many older homes have a thin mortar layer instead of a real crown, and those crack and crumble over time.
CSIA recommends a crown that sticks out past all sides of the chimney by two inches so water drips clear of the brick, and the Masonry Advisory Council recommends a sloped crown with a drip edge, not a thin mortar wash. When the crown cracks, water goes straight down into the brick and the inside of the chimney.
Clue it's the crown: you see cracks or missing chunks on top of the chimney, crumbling brick near the top, or water showing up inside the fireplace.
3. A Missing or Damaged Chimney Cap
The cap is the metal cover over the flue opening. Without one, rain and snow fall right down the chimney. CSIA notes a good cap also keeps out birds and animals and acts as a spark arrestor.
Clue it's the cap: water or dampness inside the firebox, a rusty damper, or a musty smell from the fireplace after rain.
4. Porous or Worn Brick and Mortar
Even with good flashing and a good crown, old brick and worn mortar joints can soak up enough water to cause trouble. Look for:
- White staining (efflorescence) on the brick. That's salt left behind when water moves through the masonry and evaporates.
- Spalling, where the face of the brick flakes or pops off.
- Mortar joints that are sandy, recessed, or missing.
Spalling and crumbling mortar are freeze-thaw damage in action, and they usually call for a mason to repoint or rebuild part of the chimney.
Does Your Chimney Need a Cricket?
A cricket (sometimes called a saddle) is a small peaked section of roof built on the uphill side of a chimney. It splits water and snow so they flow around the chimney instead of piling up behind it.
This one is in Ohio code. The Residential Code of Ohio (section 1003.20) requires a cricket when the side of the chimney facing the ridge is more than 30 inches wide and the chimney doesn't sit on the ridgeline. The cricket also has to be flashed and counterflashed like the rest of the chimney.
Wide chimneys on older Cleveland, Lakewood, and Shaker Heights homes often don't have one. Snow and ice dam up behind the chimney all winter, and that's a classic leak spot. If you're replacing your roof, it's the right time to add one.
What You Can Do Right Now
- Check the attic on a rainy or melting day. Look at the wood around the chimney for wet spots, dark stains, or frost.
- Look from the ground with binoculars for loose or bent flashing, a crumbling crown, a missing cap, or stained brick.
- Put a bucket or towel down if water is coming in, and take photos. Photos help your roofer and, if it was storm damage, your insurance company.
- Don't climb up on a snowy or icy roof. No leak is worth a fall.
Our post on what to do about a roof leak in winter walks through the short-term steps. If you're also seeing icicles and water at the eaves, read our ice dam prevention guide.
Who Fixes What: Roofer or Chimney Sweep?
A chimney leak can involve two trades, and it helps to know who to call:
- A roofer handles flashing, counterflashing, crickets, and the shingles around the chimney.
- A chimney professional or mason handles the crown, cap, brick, mortar, and the flue liner.
If you use your fireplace or have a gas furnace or water heater venting through the chimney, have it inspected every year. CSIA follows National Fire Protection Association Standard 211, which says chimneys, fireplaces, and vents should be inspected at least once a year. Gas-vented chimneys count too, since nests and debris can block the flue.
Get a Free Chimney Flashing and Roof Inspection
We'll get up on the roof, check your flashing, counterflashing, and the shingles around your chimney, look for a missing cricket, and tell you straight whether it's a roofing problem or a masonry problem. You'll get photos and a clear, itemized estimate. No pressure.
We inspect and repair roofs across Northeast Ohio, including Cleveland, Lakewood, Parma, Shaker Heights, Elyria, Medina, and Mentor. Learn more about our roof repair and roof inspection services. Inspections and quotes are always free.
Pring Roofing has served Northeast Ohio since 1936. We're fully insured, hold a BBB A+ rating, and are an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, an Elevate (formerly Firestone) Licensed Applicator, and a Carlisle authorized applicator.
Call (216) 941-6298 or email contact@pringroofing.com, or request a free quote online. We answer 7 days a week, 7am to 10pm.
Sources: Chimney Safety Institute of America (CSIA), "Water Damage to Chimneys" and Homeowner Resources (citing NFPA 211); Masonry Advisory Council, "Chimney Construction"; Residential Code of Ohio, Section 1003.20 Chimney Crickets (Ohio Admin. Code 4101:8-10-01); U.S. EPA Burn Wise, "Wood-Burning Installation and Maintenance." This post is general information. Every roof and chimney is different, so get yours looked at before deciding on a repair.
